I’ve been with Geico for a long time, and while my rate went up around $42 per month when I lost my low mileage discount, I still find their service good. Someone I know in Tampa, Florida, pays around $400 a month just for auto with Amica, but that’s for a Honda Passport and a Toyota 4Runner, and they also have home, boat, and flood insurance bundled for a total of $1600 a month.