When I was looking for pet insurance, Embrace, Lemonade, Odie, and Wagmo were the cheapest for my dog and cat. However, pricing really varies based on breed, location, and age, so getting quotes from multiple providers is the best way to compare. For example, I’ve seen quotes for a 2.5-month-old puppy from Trupanion for $150 per month, while someone else pays only $50 for a 10-year-old dog.